Cake Balls and Cake PopsEvansville, IN Area

Little bites.
Big moments.

Signature cake balls decorated to match their flavor, custom orders in your colors, and cake pops by the piece. Order online, choose your pickup day, and pay by card.

❤️ Loved by 4,100+ fans on Facebook
Shop cake balls Custom order
A colorful assortment of decorated cake balls The Cake Ball Lady gift boxes of cake balls Decorated cake pops on sticks Pastel decorated cake balls A box of assorted cake balls Cakesicles on sticks Elegant all-white cake balls Teddy bear baby shower cake pops Butler University team-colored cake balls Indiana football themed cake balls Patriotic red, white and blue cake pops and cakesicles

Order online

Start by choosing your pickup day, then pick your flavors and add to your order. Signature style means each cake ball is decorated to look like its flavor.

1

Choose your pickup day

Your pickup day sets which flavors you can order. Ordering 2+ weeks ahead unlocks the full Signature Decoration flavor menu. Pickups Tue–Sat; orders close 2 days before at 5pm.

👆 Choose your pickup day above to see flavors and start your order.

Want custom colors, a theme, or custom-decoration gift boxes? Custom orders start at $26/dozenrequest a quote below.

Gift box orders have a $20 minimum (cake balls & pops count toward it).

Flavors

Classics are available year-round. Premium flavors rotate — here's what's being made this week.

Classic flavors

Available any time, year-round

Premium flavors

Rotating — may need a little longer turnaround
Available this week

Don't see a premium flavor you want this week? Ask on a custom order — most can be made with extra notice.

Seasonal specials

Limited-time treats for the season, plus a heads-up on the next holiday to order ahead for.

Custom orders

Tell us about your event and we'll send a quote within 48 hours. Once it's priced, you'll get a link to pay by card. Custom-decoration gift boxes are ordered here too.

From $26/dozen 2 colors included 2 flavors per dozen Custom gift boxes 2 weeks notice

Custom orders need at least 2 weeks notice. Need it sooner? Message The Cake Ball Lady to see if she can accommodate a shorter turnaround.

Your request goes straight to The Cake Ball Lady. She'll send a quote within 48 hours, along with a link to pay by card.

Frequently asked questions